Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Inadequacy of the "Anti-Zionist " label

When I saw this FB post from the Jewish Council of Australia announcing an interview with author Molly Crabapple, I was intrigued:  https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1E3xqqy4Sf/

I did not have time then to listen to the interview, but I did make this comment on the FB post:

 “Looking forward to listening to the episode. My question: How much of the continuing European antisemitism culminating in the Holocaust (and restrictive immigration policies in the West) make the creation of Israel in 1948 a necessity? And what do we do now with the impact of the recent triumphs of the Jabotinsky version of Zionism?”

 

I just listened to the interview.  As much as I appreciate Molly Crabapple’s historical research (which resonates so much with my own family’s history in Tsarist Russia), her answer to my questions only partially satisfied me.  She did recognize the impact of the West’s anti-Jewish immigration policies even in the wake of the Holocaust.  But her posture as an "anti-Zionist" did not address the question of what we (and still I say "we") should do now. 

 

Millions of Jews were born in modern Israel. There is no place else for most of them to go.  Just as there was no place for many of their parents and grandparents to go.  And the tragic history of the human species is that many countries, like our own, are populated by descendants of people who displaced others.  


It is also important to remember that those doing the displacing were often ghemselves displaced by others.  Human history did not begin in 1948.  Those facts, however, do not justify the oppression of those who lived in the land before them.  Before the end of World War I, most Palestinians were oppressed by the Ottoman Empire and their absentee landlords; and for centuries, Jews in the European Diaspora were oppressed by the European regimes, culminating in the Holocaust.  In a tragic sense, the Nakba and the Holocaust were two sides of the same coin.

 

Absent a two-state solution (which, admittedly, looks farther and farther away) or a secular state “from the River to the Sea” (which looks like even more of a pipe dream given the damage that has been done by and to “both sides”), it is hard to see a good path forward. 

 

The hardest, saddest, most tragic question is WHAT DO WE DO NOW?  Simple anti-Zionism as expressed by Ms. Crabapple, does not provide an answer.   Leverage that the U.S. Government and the Diaspora Community might have used years ago to steer against the Jabotinsky maximalist position, which has morphed into Kahanism (you can look it up), was not used when it might have had more of an impact.

 

But Progressive Israeli groups, like the Israel Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism and the newly-formed Democratic Party in Israel -- who identify as Zionists --  are valiantly trying to move toward peace and justice, including the inclusion of Israeli Arab political parties in the next government. As are many Diaspora Jews, including brave rabbis and others, like Representative-Elect Brad Lander, who identify as Zionists, have been helping.   Pro-Israel (as distinct from pro-Netanyahu) American political leaders increasingly understand that continuing to provide a blank check to Netanyahu and his allies makes it more difficult for everyone to ever achieve peace and justice.  It is significant to note that those political leaders are not "anti-Israel."  Rather, they make it clear that they are against actions of the current Israeli government -- actions which are making it more difficult for Israel to flourish as a democratic state.  This is no different than Americans who are against the Trump Government, but are also patriotic Americans.


An "anti-Zionist" who does not grapple with ALL the human complexities of the situation does the cause of justice and peace for Palestinians no good. Just as a "Zionist" who does not deal with these complexities (other than to effectively advocate for oppression or expulsion from territory under the government's control), does the cause of justice and peace  for Israeli Jews no good.


We need to stop digging the hole that the Jabotinsky maximalists have been digging for years.  We can only hope it is not too late.

 

Here is the link to the podcast: 

https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/latenightlive/molly-crabapple-bund/107391932?fbclid=IwY2xjawVpbktleHRuA2FlbQIxMABwZG9mBWJyaWQRMU11S0MzRmtZa3ZQb3pYM3RzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEfaQ4hoq-83vuWvnjdhJkzOh7sfEAQXjbCA-R8MbmT3wFrbgm0L77DGS4UYEM_aem_jdVzzqFwX8bOzAFp6Mdj7w